Go Back
Jimmy Johns Oil and Vinegar Recipe

Jimmy Johns Oil and Vinegar Recipe

This Jimmy Johns Oil and Vinegar Recipe is the secret to making "freaky fast" subs at home. It features a perfectly balanced blend of high-quality oil and tangy red wine vinegar.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Course Condiment/Dressing
Cuisine American Deli Style
Servings 8
Calories 120 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • 3/4 cup high-quality soybean oil or light olive oil
  • 1/4 cup red wine vinegar look for 5% acidity
  • A pinch of dried oregano optional for herb flavor
  • A tiny pinch of salt optional for seasoning

Instructions
 

Choose Your Bottle

  • Select a clean glass bottle or a jar that has a very tight and secure lid for shaking. Glass is best because it does not change the flavor of the oil or the vinegar over time.

Measure the Oil

  • Pour exactly three-quarters of a cup of soybean oil or light olive oil into your chosen glass container. This provides the smooth, rich base that coats the bread and toppings perfectly every time you pour.

Add the Vinegar

  • Slowly add one-quarter cup of red wine vinegar into the bottle using your small funnel to prevent spills. This specific 3-to-1 ratio is the industry secret for a perfectly balanced deli-style sandwich dressing.

Add Optional Herbs

  • If you want an Italian sub vibe, add a tiny pinch of dried oregano to the liquid mix. This is not strictly in the base recipe, but it adds a lovely savory aroma to sandwiches.

Secure the Lid

  • Make sure the lid is twisted on very tight to prevent any oil from leaking out during the mix. Give the bottle a quick wipe with a towel to ensure a firm and safe grip.

Shake Vigorously

  • Shake the bottle up and down for at least thirty seconds until the oil and vinegar are well blended. You will see the liquid turn into a beautiful, cloudy, and consistent pale red mixture.

Let it Settle

  • Allow the mixture to sit for a minute or two so the flavors can begin to meld together. You will notice the oil and vinegar start to separate again, which is completely normal for this.

Prep the Bread

  • Slice your fresh sub roll open and lay it flat on your clean cutting board or a plate. It is best to apply the dressing directly onto the bread or the shredded lettuce for flavor.

Drizzle the Dressing

  • Give the bottle one more quick shake right before you are ready to pour it onto your sandwich. Drizzle a light, even stream across the length of the sub for the most consistent deli taste.

Close and Serve

  • Fold your sandwich closed and let it sit for thirty seconds so the oil can soak in slightly. Your Jimmy Johns style sub is now ready to be enjoyed with your favorite chips and a drink.

Notes

  • Use soybean oil if you want the most authentic and neutral "store-bought" flavor for your subs.
  • Light olive oil is a great, healthier alternative that still has a very mild and pleasant taste.
  • Always use red wine vinegar rather than white vinegar to get that specific tangy and fruity bite.
  • Store your dressing at room temperature so the oil does not get thick or cloudy in the cold.
  • Add a half-teaspoon of Italian seasoning if you prefer a much bolder and more herbal dressing style.
  • Use a squeeze bottle with a thin tip to control the flow and prevent a soggy sandwich.
Keyword Jimmy Johns Oil and Vinegar Recipe